Image default

The Greatest Colanders of 2022

Straight to the Level

Our favourite general colander was the RSVP International Endurance Stainless Steel Precision Pierced Colander; it was each light-weight and sturdy, and efficiently drained orzo with none slipping by the holes. For an over-the-sink model colander, we appreciated the U.S. Kitchen Supply Over The Sink Stainless Steel Oval Colander. This mannequin had expandable handles that saved the entire thing sturdy even when pasta sloshed into it.

In case you love noodles as a lot as we do (and we’re prepared to guess you do) you want a colander to empty them. Light-weight, fine mesh strainers are helpful for plenty of tasks, however for heavy batches of pasta or enormous bushels of greens, a big, free-standing or over-the-sink colander is the fitting instrument for the job.

To search out the most effective fashions, we examined eight in style colanders, specializing in ones that have been 5 quarts, which is spacious sufficient for draining and holding a pound of cooked pasta. We included a wide range of supplies (chrome steel, plastic, silicone) and types of strainers (wonderful mesh, bigger holes, and all-over, tiny perforations). Here is what we discovered—however, first, a take a look at our favourite colanders.

The Winners, at a Look

The Greatest Colander: RSVP Worldwide Endurance Stainless Metal Precision Pierced Colander, 5-Quart

Skinny chrome steel helped this colander obtain a steadiness between light-weight and sturdy. It drained rapidly, and its handles stayed cool to the contact after being doused with boiling water. The small holes saved even the tiniest bits of pasta from escaping. And its {smooth} floor and tightly-sealed rim simply cleaned and did not entice noodles or greens.

The Greatest Over-the-Sink Colander: U.S. Kitchen Provide Over-The-Sink Stainless Metal Oval Colander 

U.S. Kitchen Supply stainless steel over the sink colander

Essentially the most surefire approach to stop water washing again up right into a colander is an over-the-sink mannequin. This strainer featured extendable handles that stretch out to span almost two toes. They have been simple to broaden and collapse, and remained sturdy beneath the load of one-pound of meals. When you have an extra-large sink, measure the width earlier than ordering to ensure this colander will match. 

The Checks

Tiny, all-over perforations equated to raised drainage.

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi

  • Straining Angel Hair Pasta Check: We cooked and strained one-pound of angel hair pasta utilizing a stopwatch to time how lengthy it took the pasta to utterly drain. We additionally inspected the colander to see if any noodles escaped or have been poking out.
  • Straining Orzo Check: We cooked and strained one pound of orzo, utilizing a stopwatch to time how lengthy it took the pasta to utterly drain. We additionally inspected the colander to see if any noodles escaped or have been poking out.
  • Straining Broccoli Check: We boiled and strained one pound of broccoli florets. We then cleaned every colander to see if any small bits of broccoli remained caught within the holes or beneath the rim.
  • Usability and Cleanup Checks: All through testing, we evaluated how simple the colanders have been to arrange, choose up, and in any other case deal with. We washed every colander by hand after each check. On the finish of testing, we cleaned every colander within the dishwasher in line with their producer care directions to see how they held up.

What We Discovered

Gap Measurement Was Necessary for Drainage

When it got here to draining, colanders with giant perforations got here in on the backside of our assessments, permitting orzo to flee.

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi

When it got here to draining, gap measurement and placement impacted efficiency. The simplest colanders had small, evenly-spaced holes all alongside their partitions and bases. These allowed water to empty out rapidly with none meals escaping. Some fashions, just like the KitchenAid classic plastic colander, had different gap sizes, with plenty of house between them (20 millimeters in comparison with the .5 millimeters of our favourite colander). Extra space meant extra stable floor space, which slowed drainage. Poorer-performing fashions took upwards of 10 seconds longer to empty than the RSVP.

Moreover, bigger holes (like those on the KitchenAid and All-Clad Stainless Steel Colander) allowed meals to flee, creating waste. When examined with orzo, these fashions left the sink filled with tiny noodles.

An Over-the-Sink Colander Helped Stop Dreaded Backwash

In case your sink drains slowly, we advocate getting an over-the-sink colander. If not, a standalone colander with a tall base and quick drainage will work nice.

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi

To make use of a free-standing colander, you place it within the kitchen sink and pour instantly from a pot into the colander. If the colander drains slowly, or in case your sink is backed up, there’s a threat that water from the sink may wash again up into the colander, contaminating your meals and ruining your day. We love our kitchen sinks, however we completely don’t wish to lick them, and cross contamination between the sink and our dinner is a no-go. Essentially the most foolproof approach to keep away from that is to make use of an over-the-sink colander. With a mannequin just like the U.S. Kitchen Supply, the underside of the colander doesn’t contact the sink. So after the water runs by the mesh, there’s zero probability of it washing again up.

In case your sink drains usually, a free-standing mannequin with a quick drain time and tall (one-inch) base, like our favourite from RSVP, will work simply wonderful.

Textured Holes Trapped Meals Bits

The diamond-shaped mesh of the Williams Sonoma colander tore at and trapped meals.

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi

All colander partitions have holes—that’s form of the purpose. The issue is that any uneven edges create a spot the place meals can get caught. The Bellemain Micro-Perforated Stainless Steel Colander drained effectively, however its holes had barely raised edges that snagged small noodles and broccoli fibers. Wire mesh fashions, just like the one from Williams Sonoma, confronted an identical downside. Though they have been the quick drainers, any little piece of meals left behind needed to be delicately extracted earlier than the partitions tore it aside like a cheese grater.

Giant, Simple-to-Grip Handles Have been Greatest

Handles are a should for retaining your palms out of the best way of sloshing noodles or wafts of steam. Our favourite fashions featured handles giant sufficient to seize securely with three fingers (no less than three inches broad). The OXO Good Grips stainless steel colander was the one mannequin with no handles. As an alternative, it featured a silicone edge with barely wider silicone space for lifting. These hard-to-grip handles put our palms proper within the motion, and elevated our chance of dropping the entire thing.

The Standards: What We Search for in a Good Colander

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi / Amanda Suarez

The perfect colander ought to be stable and reliable. Our favourite fashions have been fast-draining and nimble. They held regular beneath the power of a pound of pasta, and had sturdy handles that made transferring meals a breeze (and saved our palms secure from scalding). We additionally regarded for a colander floor that felt {smooth} to the contact—the less ragged edges, the much less probably it was to entice meals. 

The Greatest Colander: RSVP Worldwide Endurance Stainless Metal Precision Pierced Colander

Stainless steel colander on white background

What we appreciated: This sturdy, no-frills colander drained extremely rapidly (the second quickest of the bunch). Sturdy, broad handles made it simple to carry onto, too. The colander’s partitions and base had a whole lot of tiny, minimally spaced holes, which allowed water to flee, however nonetheless contained each final little bit of meals. The RSVP’s partitions have been {smooth} to the contact and simple to wipe clear after use.

What we didn’t like: There have been no evident flaws on this primary mannequin. In case your sink drains slowly, there is a slight threat water may again up into the colander, however that’s no fault of the colander itself. (And if it is a identified downside, you may wish to think about investing in an over-the-sink mannequin.)

Key Specs

  • Weight: 14.9 ounces
  • Product dimensions: 13 x 11 x 5 inches
  • Base peak: 1-inch 
  • Supplies: Chrome steel
  • Care directions: Dishwasher-safe

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi

The Greatest Over-the-Sink Colander: U.S. Kitchen Provide Over-the-Sink Stainless Metal Oval Colander 

U.S. Kitchen Supply stainless steel over the sink colander

What we appreciated: This over-the-sink design is the easiest way to keep away from water backwash. The handles prolonged and collapsed simply for simpler use and storage and their rubber grips supplied loads of stability. We discovered this mannequin stayed in place even when heavy meals have been poured into it.

What we didn’t like: The mesh base of this colander was quick-draining and light-weight, however much less sturdy than chrome steel options. Wire mesh can bend or dent if saved improperly or vigorously scrubbed.

Key Specs

  • Weight: 1.45 lbs
  • Product dimensions: 5.71 x 3.74 x 1.38 inches; handles span 21 inches when expanded 
  • Base peak: 1/2-inch
  • Supplies: Chrome steel; rubber
  • Care directions: Dishwasher-safe

Critical Eats / Madeline Muzzi

The Competitors

  • Bellemain Micro-perforated Stainless Steel: The Bellemain was a stable colander with many similarities to the profitable RSVP Worldwide. Nonetheless, bits of orzo and broccoli received caught beneath the rim of this chrome steel mannequin, making it more durable to wash. The marginally raised, perforated holes of the Bellemain created a tough floor that caught small strands of broccoli. 
  • KitchenAid Classic Plastic Colander: This plastic colander drained slowly. Though the graceful plastic was simple to wash, the big holes allowed orzo and the tail ends of angle hair pasta to flee. 
  • OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Colander: This colander drained effectively, however the small rubber handles have been troublesome to seize. Though they remained cool to the contact, they positioned your palms near the motion and have been slippery.
  • Williams Sonoma Stainless-Steel 3-Piece Mesh Colander Set: We liked the super-fast drainage of this mesh colander. However, throughout cleansing, the wire mesh had a cheese grater impact on caught meals: it caught and ripped aside small noodles and bits of broccoli. The mesh can even bend off form. 
  • All-Clad Stainless Steel Colander: This stable colander drained rapidly and was simple to deal with. Sadly, the big holes allowed a big quantity of orzo to flee. At $80, it is also extremely costly.
  • Qimh Over-the-Sink Colander: This over-the-sink colander misplaced factors for design and drain time. The inconsistently distributed holes contributed to a sluggish drain. The expandable handles have been additionally troublesome to break down, making it awkward to switch meals from the colander to a serving vessel. 


What’s the distinction between a colander and strainer?

The phrases colander and strainer are sometimes used interchangeably. Each of those instruments are used to separate solids from liquids, however the designs could fluctuate. Colanders are giant, sturdy, and bowl-shaped. They’re usually footed and free-standing. Strainers are smaller mesh instruments with lengthy handles—helpful for duties like making silky-smooth pastry cream, sifting flour, and more.

What’s the easiest way to wash a colander?

The trick to cleansing a colander is to get began instantly. Meals left to sit down in a colander can dry out and get caught in its small holes and crevices. After you’ve transferred meals out of the colander and into one other vessel, merely wash and dry with cleaning soap and water or place within the dishwasher. You should definitely double examine for any bits of caught meals. In case you do end up with cussed meals particles, let your colander soak in heat, soapy water for a bit earlier than cleansing.

What measurement is a standard colander?

We advocate selecting a colander that is roughly the identical measurement as your cooking vessel. Most pasta pots maintain between six to eight quarts of water, and are usually crammed about 3/4 full. This implies a 5-quart colander is definitely sufficiently big to pressure a pound of pasta.

Related posts

Maqlubeh Recipe


Smothered Pork Chops | The Recipe Critic


Banana Cream Pie Recipe