Image default

Practically R90 billion in unclaimed belongings, says FSCA

The whole worth of unclaimed belongings in SA is now round R90 billion, with roughly half of that being unclaimed pension funds. Collective funding schemes and life insurers maintain an extra 38% of unclaimed belongings.

Chatting with the media on Wednesday, Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) commissioner Unathi Kamlana mentioned the quantum of funds unclaimed throughout all monetary sectors stays a priority, although good progress has been made in tracing beneficiaries in recent times.

In 2020, 97 227 pension fund beneficiaries had been paid out R3.45 billion. This brings the overall unclaimed advantages paid throughout the decade from 2010 to 2020 to about R37.7 billion, to greater than 1.3 million beneficiaries.

Regardless of the rise in worth of unclaimed advantages over time, the variety of members with unclaimed advantages has declined since 2018.

Supply – FSCA

Central securities depository members (CSDPs), accountable for processing dividend transfers, had unclaimed belongings of R4.5 billion belonging to 391 000 account holders in 2019.

Supply – FSCA

The 5 banks canvassed by the FSCA had 5.7 million dormant accounts with R3.36 billion in funds.

Higher vigour wanted

Whereas each effort is reportedly being made to trace down the rightful homeowners of those belongings, the FSCA recommends establishing a centralised database of unclaimed funds, and a devoted ‘central unclaimed belongings fund’ to obtain and handle unclaimed belongings.

Alternatively, the funds needs to be transferred to the Nationwide Income Fund for administration rather than leaving them underneath the management of monetary establishments.

These unclaimed funds may very well be invested for the general public good, specializing in social, environmental and developmental upliftment.

The FSCA additionally proposes a minimal threshold for unclaimed belongings, under which belongings is not going to be actively traced.

Kathy Gibson, deputy commissioner on the FSCA, mentioned it’s unlucky that the folks most impacted by the phenomenon of unclaimed belongings are probably the most susceptible.

“We don’t profess to have all of the solutions however need to have sturdy and wider engagement about how one can find beneficiaries and minimise the build-up of those unclaimed belongings over time.”

How did the determine get to R90 billion?

A number of causes had been superior for the build-up in unclaimed belongings:

  • Monetary establishments’ failure to replace contact and private particulars of beneficiaries, and to tell them that they’ve unclaimed belongings;
  • Insufficient record-keeping by monetary establishments and intermediaries;
  • An inconsistent method to figuring out and treating unclaimed belongings throughout the monetary sector;
  • Modifications in intermediaries and fund directors typically leading to admin neglect; and
  • Employers failing to supply retirement funds and their directors with all the main points on fund members.

On the finish of 2020, there have been 1 306 retirement funds holding unclaimed advantages of R47.2 billion on behalf of 4.45 million beneficiaries, with greater than three-quarters of those held in occupational funds.

The place the majority lies …

The sectors with the best quantity of unclaimed belongings are occupational funds within the mining, motor, steel and engineering industries.

In keeping with an Open Secrets and techniques report based mostly on 2017 figures, the funds with by far the most important quantity of unclaimed advantages are the Metallic Industries Profit Fund (practically R19 billion) and the Mineworkers Fund (R4.3 billion).

As Moneyweb reported, poor company admin is partly responsible for the quantity of unclaimed belongings, however a far greater downside [in the past] was the variety of migrant staff travelling to the mines from Malawi, Mozambique, Lesotho and elsewhere.

Employees with conventional African names that had been laborious to pronounce got names that suited the directors.

ALSO READ: Dirty little secret behind SA’s R50bn in unclaimed pension benefits


Olano Makhubela​​, head of retirement fund supervision on the FSCA, mentioned it’s troublesome to elucidate the focus of unclaimed advantages in simply two funds with out speaking about apartheid.

“Black folks couldn’t be employed in high-paying jobs, so that they gravitated in direction of manufacturing and mining. Report-keeping was a problem for employers, and other people had been [sometimes] given IDs that had been actually a stream of zeros.”

Migrant staff returned residence, abandoning any declare they needed to pension fund advantages constructed up through the years, and admin data received misplaced – intentionally or in any other case – when firms went bust, merged or retrenched staff.


A degree typically raised by these chasing down unclaimed advantages, such because the Unclaimed Advantages Committee (UPC), is the disincentive to actively hint beneficiaries when the fund managers earn such beneficiant charges on unclaimed belongings.

That might quantity to 2% to three% a yr, equal to between R900 million and R2.7 billion on the R90 billion the FSCA says is unclaimed.

That annual payment revenue would disappear if the asset homeowners had been discovered.

At a recent People’s Hearing on Unpaid Pensions on Structure Hill in Johannesburg, a number of audio system informed of their frustration in attempting to trace down funds they believed had been owed to them.

“I’ve lodged claims, however nothing has come to fruition. Nobody is coming ahead to elucidate the best way ahead,” mentioned Andrew Zwane, a member of the UPC.

A few of these belongings have been unclaimed for many years, and lots of the homeowners have handed on, leaving it to their beneficiaries to select up the cudgels on their behalf.

Worry of ‘infiltration’

One of many fears round establishing a brand new central asset administration operation is the potential for infiltration by political or personal pursuits.

The FSCA says this may be mitigated by leveraging constructions similar to Nedlac, the place enterprise, labour and authorities are represented. “[The] board of the central fund [should be] accountable for taking operational selections, together with ranges of reserves to satisfy future claims and degree of distribution,” says the FSCA presentation.

Useful homeowners should have the suitable to reclaim, in perpetuity, the worth of the belongings on the level of switch into the receiving fund, be it a central fund or the Nationwide Income Fund, in addition to any accrued curiosity between the date of switch and the date of reclaim.

The reclaim of funds also needs to be tax impartial, with belongings being taxed on the date of reclaim relatively than date of entry into the fund.

A standardised method to monitoring and tracing homeowners of unclaimed belongings is required, with monetary establishments being duty-bound to take care of detailed and present data on issues similar to dormant accounts and unclaimed belongings.

These data ought to embrace the variety of accounts and helpful homeowners, asset kind, particular person asset worth, age of asset, age and race of a helpful proprietor, how the establishment has responded to tracing helpful homeowners, and the effectiveness of such responses.

This text initially appeared on Moneyweb and was republished with permission.
Learn the unique article here.

Related posts

Springboks will carry on shrugging off Aussies’ sly techniques: ‘We do not take shortcuts’


Inflation cools to 7.6% – however meals costs stay purple sizzling


Fiji and Australia on high of the Sevens World